Commissioners voted 5-1 to demolish the empty work-release center near Kaley Street. Staff put demolition at $400,000 and a housing refit near $30 million.
The Orange County Board of County Commissioners voted 5-1 on Nov. 10 to demolish the county’s former work-release center near Kaley Street, an empty corrections building in Orlando that housing advocates had asked the county to turn into a shelter.
Commissioner Mike Scott, whose District 6 includes the site, moved staff’s recommendation. Commissioner Nicole H. Wilson seconded it. The vote is on the county’s own Orange TV video of the Nov. 10 meeting, where Mayor Jerry L. Demings announced the 5-1 result.
Overview
- What was decided: the building comes down. The parking lot stays, because the Supervisor of Elections office across the street uses it for overflow parking.
- What it costs: about $400,000 to demolish, paid from an existing county capital project.
- What it saves: $175,000 to $200,000 a year the county spends keeping the empty building secure and running.
- What happens to the land: staff said the county does not intend to sell it. A future board will decide what goes there.
Why staff wanted it demolished
Sarah Flynn Kramer, manager of the county’s Capital Projects Division, presented the case. Her presentation starts about 2 hours, 12 minutes into the meeting video.
The center stopped operating as a work-release site when COVID-19 arrived in 2020, she said. In 2022 the corrections department confirmed it had no further use for it. The building has been empty since, with major maintenance put off for years.
Kramer gave the board these figures:
| Item | Staff estimate |
|---|---|
| Demolition of the building only | about $400,000 |
| Yearly cost of keeping it empty (power, guards, grounds) | $175,000 to $200,000 |
| Repairs just to get the building working again | more than $5 million |
| Replacing the failed main chiller | $375,000 to $500,000 |
| Refitting it as safe housing for all genders | close to $30 million |
A $4.1 million project to replace the air conditioning and water pipes has been on hold since 2017, she said. Parts of the main chiller failed in October and replacement parts cannot be found. Staff also suspect plumbing leaks inside the floor slabs, and the electrical system is original and not up to code.
The building was designed as a single-gender correctional facility. Kramer said it would be cheaper to demolish it and build new than to convert it for any kind of housing.
What could go there instead
Staff showed the board one example of what the land could hold within the city of Orlando’s rules: a building of up to eight stories, an eight-story parking garage and a warehouse.
The county’s space study had looked at the site as a home for county offices now in leased space, Kramer said. That includes the Supervisor of Elections, the Tax Collector and the Property Appraiser. She said the land could also serve homeless services again. No decision on a future use was asked for or made.
The case for waiting
Commissioner Kelly Martinez Semrad, who joined the meeting online, asked the board to pause. She said she heard a disconnect between what residents were asking for and what the county planned, and that a short pause for more dialogue would not be a bad thing.
Commissioner Mike Crabb said he did not agree with a pause. He said he was shocked the county had been spending about $200,000 a year on an empty building, and that a corrections facility is not designed to be a shelter.
Scott thanked the advocacy group Save Orlando Shelters, which he said comes to the board every week. He said many of the county’s homeless services are already concentrated in his district and that new ones should be spread across the county, citing the Goldenrod shelter.
Wilson said the city of Orlando had once sought to use the property as a shelter before deciding against it. Asked by Scott, county staff said there had been no recent request from the city about the site.
Why the county no longer needs it
Demings said the county still runs a work-release program, now inside the main corrections campus. The jail’s average daily population is about 2,900, he said. When the work-release center was open it was over 4,000, even though the county has since grown to almost 1.6 million people.
What it means for you
- If you use the Supervisor of Elections office at 119 W. Kaley St., its overflow parking across the street stays. Staff said only the building will be demolished.
- If you were hoping for a shelter on this site, that is off the table for now. The land stays in county hands, and staff said a future board will decide how to use it.
- For taxpayers, staff said demolition ends a yearly holding cost of up to $200,000. Money left in the existing capital project after demolition goes back to the county.
The county has not published a demolition date.
Have your say